Ecological and Evolutionary Constraints on the Temperature Dependence of the Carbon Cycle

What are the ecological and evolutionary constraints the carbon cycle? Today I review of a talk given by Dr. Gabriel Yvon-Durocher, Chair in Ecology at the Environment and Sustainability Institute at the University of Exeter. Yvon-Durocher wants to understand what mechanisms constrain the temperature dependence behind the key fluxes of the global carbon cycle. Metabolism drives many of the physiological fluxes in the carbon cycle. Yvon-Durocher thus questions how we can understand the temperature dependence of metabolism scales from the biochemical kinetics seen at the organismal scale through ecosystem scale temperature dependence, as well as global variation behind the key fluxes in the carbon cycle. We can make these examinations by starting with what we know. We know that the carbon cycle plays a fundamental role in regulating climate. Photosynthesis and respiration systematically add and remove carbon from the biosphere, and they approximately balance each other globally. Knowing how temperature constrains and controls these key fluxes in the carbon cycle strongly contributes to our ability to assess how human impact greenhouse gas dynamics.

What mechanisms determine how temperature influences carbon fluxes at the ecosystem level? Organism physiology, ecological dynamics, and evolutionary dynamics all impact ecosystem metabolism. At the small scale, physiology involves the acute effects of temperature on biochemical kinetics. Metabolic pathways are all catalyzed by enzymes, which interact with substrates in a temperature dependent fashion. Ecological dynamics indirectly influence ecosystem metabolism by altering species interactions, abundance, and biomass distributions within ecosystems. This is because ecosystem metabolism derives from the individuals that make up the ecosystem itself.  Similarly, evolutionary dynamics make indirect impacts by shaping and determining the frequency of metabolic traits within populations. These factors not only feed back into organism scale physiology, they also play an important role in shaping ecological dynamics mentioned earlier. How temperature affects metabolism at the scale of ecosystems is therefore a complex issue that requires understanding across multiple biological, spatial, and temporal scales. These concepts tie into metabolic theory.

Gillooly et al. 2001 described the effects of body size and temperature on metabolic rate. The following equation from their paper describes the exponential relationship between metabolic rate and temperature:

screen-shot-2017-03-01-at-10-39-32-pm

Where B is biomass, M is metabolic rate, k is the Boltzmann constant, and T is temperature. The equation shows that temperature dependence is determined by the activation energy, . Taking the natural log of the exponential metabolic rate and the activation energy produces a straight line with slope . When body size is accounted for, the activation energy is remarkably conserved among different types of organisms. However, there are notable implicit assumptions in this model:

  1. Analysis is interspecific across taxa even though the basic Boltzmann model has been applied at intraspecific and interspecific scales.
  2. The effects of temperature are the same with within versus between species; evolution does not compensate for the thermodynamics effects of temperature.

Bibliography:

Gillooly, J. F. (2001). Effects of Size and Temperature on Metabolic Rate. Science,293(5538), 2248-2251. doi:10.1126/science.1061967

 

Ecological and Evolutionary Constraints on the Temperature Dependence of the Carbon Cycle

Big Ecology: The Emergence of Ecosystem Science in North American and the World

 

The International Geophysical Year (1957-1958) marked a period open collaboration between the East and West during the Cold War. Sixty-seven countries participated in the program, which encompassed eleven Earth sciences (aurora and airglow, cosmic rays, geomagnetism, gravity, ionospheric physics, precision mapping, meteorology, oceanography, seismology, and solar activity). Timing of the program proved advantageous; research was actively pursued to fuel the space race after Sputnik was launched. United States Congress appropriated $44 million for orbiting satellite studies, as well as oceanic and terrestrial studies. Other agencies contributed approximately $400 million, which ensured the program’s completion.

 

Pioneers in big ecology emanated from the Atomic Energy Commission. Early work stemmed from concerns expressed within the Commission by the Dr. John Wolfe at the Environmental Division. Nascent programs then started with the Savannah River Site, Eniwetok Atoll study, Oak Ridge National Lab, Puerto Rico Rain Forest study (forerunner of the Luquillo LTER), and the Brookhaven forest radiation study. To name a few, Drs. Odum, Golley, Wiegert, Auerbach, Van Dyne, and Woodwell were major figures within these programs. Their work went on to pave the way for future big ecology studies.

 

Global interest in the biological productivity grew as these studies progressed. The International Biological Program (IPB) began in early 1964 across Europe, Asia, and the British Commonwealth. There was initially strong resistance to IBP in the US due to misgivings shared by biomedical biologists, who perceived the initiative as glorified fieldwork. In response, NSF meticulously awarded grants to only the most competitive and stand-alone projects to IBP. However, strong support by influential ecologists such as Gene Odum, Fred Smith, and Frank Blair at the “Williamstown meeting” in August 1966 eventually compelled US scientists to finally back it. The US IBP ultimately became the foundation for national ecological research, making principal contributions to ecosystem science, including:

  1. The importance of belowground processes in terrestrial ecosystems.
  2. The roles of canopy processes in nutrient cycling, especially N fixation.
  3. The stream continuum concept (the physical processes outside of a rice effect the biological processes along the river, which effect the physical and biological processes within it), and the corollary idea of “nutrient spiraling” (comparing paths of key nutrient uptake and release).
  4. The crucial roles that microbial processes play in ecosystem function.
  5. Necessity of conducting whole-system experiments to better understand the underlying mechanisms driving phenomena.
  6. Paramount importance of studying old growth forests, and the matures stages of other ecosystems to fully understand nutrient cycling and ecosystem resilience.
  7. The fact that ecosystems are active all year round.

 

By the Fall of 1967, Congress appropriated funds to support NSF’s new Ecosystem Analysis Program. By July 1974, this program supplanted and ended the US IBP. The rapid and front-loaded development of the IBP contrasts with the long term ecological research network (LTER), which grew more slowly and had a longer overall lifespan. LTER has been active since 1980, with 26 sites and one network office, a variety of NSF and external partners, and dynamic site locations. LTER comprises five core areas of research: pattern and control of primary production; spatial and temporal distribution of populations selected to represent trophic structure; pattern and control of organic matter accumulation in surface layers and sediments; patterns of inorganic input and movement through soils, groundwater and surface water; and patterns and frequency of disturbance to the research site. The systematic and cooperative and format of LTER has provided many research benefits. For example, Magnuson et al. were able to discover long-term trends in the dates of ice in dozens in the North Temperate Lakes study in Wisconsin. Furthermore, LTER has facilitated research showing that feedback effects ripple through entire watersheds. Defoliating insect outbreaks change nitrate loadings in streams within and leaving watershed boundaries. Finally, LTER fosters opportunities for cross-site studies, such as temperate and tropical comparisons of aboveground and belowground tropic interactions (Heneghan et al. 2008) and aquatic food webs.

 

 

 

 

Bibliography:

 

Coleman, D. C. (2010). Big ecology: the emergence of ecosystem science.

Berkeley: University of California Press. doi:10.1525/california/9780520264755.001.0001

 

Heneghan, L, SP Miller, S Baer, MA Callaham Jr, J Montgomery, M Pavao-Zuckerman, CC Rhoades and S Richardson (2008). Integrating soil ecological knowledge into restoration management. Restoration Ecology, 16(4), 608–617.

 

Big Ecology: The Emergence of Ecosystem Science in North American and the World

AGU 2016

Last December I attended the AGU Fall Meeting. I presented preliminary data on correlated EGA thermograms and 13C NMR spectra. This project is an active collaboration with Johnathan Sanderman at the Woodshole Research Center, and Jeffrey Baldock at Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation (SCaRP). National-scale inventories typically include soil organic carbon (SOC) content, but not chemical composition or biogeochemical stability. While 13C NMR is highly effective for SOM characterization, it is typically too expensive and time consuming for use in large-scale SOC monitoring. Therefore, we seek to understand if analytical thermal analysis is a viable alternative to NMR. This project has involved analyzing 300 agricultural samples collected by SCaRP, which have been divided into four fractions: whole soil, coarse particulates (POM), untreated mineral associated (HUM), and hydrofluoric acid (HF)-treated HUM. All samples have been analyzed by DSC-EGA, but only the POM and HF-HUM fractions were analyzed by NMR. The thermal and NMR data were analyzed by PCA and overlain with 2D Shige software to ascertain positive and negative correlations (as well as the intensity of these correlations). I made 5 key points in my presentation:

  1. Molecular composition is only part of the story.
  2. This due to the fact that C stability depends on soil chemistry
  3. Because thermal analysis a measure of biogeochemical stability, it may have great utility in assessing soil C dynamics
  4. DSC-EGA, NMR correlation provides dense information on SOC composition, stability, and lability
  5. We found strong positive and negative correlations between the CO2 thermograms and NMR spectra using 2D Shige.

The audience was intrigued by our findings so far. Moving forward, I will explore how mineral associations and mineralogy impact thermal data. This will entail running correlations against the DSC data.

AGU 2016

Summer Soil Institute: Part II

 

The second week of SSI pressed students to synthesize and present data that had been processed in the lab.  Lectures continued for the first half of the week, with labs in soil fauna and microbiology. Students then moved to the CSU Mountain Campus at Pingree Park to collaborate on group presentations. The week started with an engaging lecture on soil biodiversity and ecosystem services delivered by Dr. Mary Stromberger. This was followed by a discourse on soil fauna taxonomy led Dr. John Moore.  Additional presentations on soil health and microbial ecology and enzymes were given by Drs. Steve Fonte and Matthew Wallenstein respectively.

IMG_0369
Cotrufo lab traces the fate of plant litter decomposition use soils devoid of OC (composed of sand, silt, and vermiculite).

Lectures were followed by lab work. I participated in the microbiology lab, where we applied enzyme activity fluorescence assays and DNA qPCR to quantify the microbial degradation of SOM, and the biomass of fungi and bacteria in our samples. A instructional tour of Dr. Joe von Fischer’s trace gas lab was also given. Each day lab work was followed by a group discussion held at a local restaurant. Dr. Cotrufo led a conversation on litter decomposition, and Dr. Moore discussed pedagogy and education thereafter. Our final lecture was given by Dr. Keith Paustian on the impact of climate change on soils. Afterwards, we began collaboration on our final group project. Participants moved to Pingree Park to work on their final projects and enjoy CSU’s pristine mountain campus. Presentations were made using data from our labs and delivered to fellow participants and staff.  As a whole, this was an active research exercise where participants collected and processed samples, analyzed data, and applied knowledge from lectures to draw conclusions. Participants shared a celebratory dinner after the presentations.

With a 7-year history and approximately 200 alums, CSU’s Summer Soil Institute is a premier opportunity to learn about soil science. It is especially useful to those with limited soil-focused facilities at their institutions, and invaluable to those seeking a comprehensive crash course in soil science.

IMG_0387
CSU Mountain Campus, Pingree Park.
Summer Soil Institute: Part II

Summer Soil Institute: Part I

The Summer Soil Institute is a rare and immersive opportunity to study soil science both in the lab and outdoors. Centered at Colorado State University, the program takes students to the short grass steppe and Borden Memorial Forest ecosystems, where soil samples are collected and analyzed by participants. An array of techniques is then employed to process the samples over the course of two weeks. Techniques span soil pedology, SOM chemistry, fractionation, stable isotopes, fauna, microbial ecology, and gas flux. In-depth lab protocols are provided to students, in addition to hands on instruction by CSU faculty and grad students. Sampling and lab work are supplemented with intensive lectures in soil science. These experiential resources prove invaluable to participants, as they go on to apply them to research at their own universities.

SSI was initiated by a lecture in soil health by Dr. Stuart Grandy from the University of New Hampshire. Grandy discussed SOM dynamics and their connection to biological communities and physical processes. He described the evolution of society’s relationship with soil, which progressed in focus from soil fertility (<1960), to soil tilth (1960-1985), soil quality (1985-2005), and soil health (2005-present). Soil health is broadly defined as qualities that facilitate both sustainable ecosystems and human communities. Grandy’s presentation opened discussion on the need for a more exact definition of soil health to guide research in this field.

We ventured into the short grass steppe to collect sample cores and gas flux measurements the next day. Sample collection was followed by a trip to CSU’s Agricultural Research, Development and Education Center, where research was being conducted on organic matter amendments and their impact on corn production. Treatments included corn cob, bamboo stalk, and biochar (from pyrolyzed wood) amendments. Plots spanned an unaltered control, as well as corn cob and bamboo stalks addition with and without biochar. Gas flux was measured using an intricate automated system that sealed gas chambers, extracted samples, and transmitted them to an on-site PICARRO analyzer to quantify CO2, CH4 and N2O between sites.

IMG_0332
ARDEC biochar amendments.

 

Samples were also taken at the Borden Memorial Forest site, on a mountainside near Horseshoe Dam, the next day. The forest site had endured episodic fire events that impacted the surrounding vegetation. Soil samples without trees were labeled “clear cut,” while their vegetated counterparts were labeled “still standing.”  Data analysis entailed comparing results between these site conditions. Gas flux samples were taken using sealed collars that relayed emissions from the soil to portable LI-COR and PICARRO instruments. Participants were debriefed on sample processing methods—for soil fauna analysis and sieving—at the end of each respective day.

IMG_0354
Measuring GHG flux with portable LI-COR instrument.

The rest of the week was split into lectures and lab work. Participants chose between a soil chemistry and pedology lab and a soil organic matter and isotope fractionation lab. I chose the latter, which focused on tracking the fate of C in the soil matrix. The first lecture gave a comprehensive run-down on soil pedology; it was clearly and concisely delivered by Dr. Suellen Melzer, who had accompanied us for field sampling.  This was followed by a thorough lecture on soil organic carbon dynamics by Dr. Francesca Cotrufo, which I will discuss in detail in another follow-up post.  Dr. Thomas Borch proceeded to deliver two lectures on the chemistry and analysis of soil organic matter. Lectures on isotopes in soil ecology and greenhouse gas efflux were delivered by Dr. Cotrufo and Dr. Joe von Fischer respectively. Finally, students voluntarily presented ignite talks on their research projects and interests to hone their public speaking skills throughout the week. This was an engaging way to prepare participants to deliver their research at future research conferences.

Summer Soil Institute: Part I

Feyerabend’s anarchistic theory of science:

 

Our journey so far has been marked by the attempt to characterize science and ascertain how it is different from other types of knowledge. We have explored many philosophical constructs in the process. We have moved from positivism, to falsification, and then on to the theoretical structures proposed by Kuhn and Lakatos.In the process we have seen that each comes with its own pitfalls and limitations. Frustrating though this may be, it is hardly surprising. Logic is not immune to discrepancy. But in that regard, is it even possible to define the scientific method under a single and all-encompassing philosophy? Paul Feyerabend thought not.In his book Against Method: Outline of an Anarchistic Theory of Knowledge (1975) Feyerabend professed that “anything goes”; there is no one unchanging principle behind the scientific method. Ideas exist in a vacuum and we are inspired to form hypotheses based upon our collective observations. How these ideas form and take root varies considerably.

I am inclined to agree with Feyerabend on this point, for reasons that were discussed in previous blog posts. However, it should be noted that Feyerabend’s theory lies in a schema that prizes an individualistic “humanitarian attitude.” His support of an anarchistic explanation for scientific development is based on a desire to “increase liberty,” thereby maximizing the human experience. On this point, I disagree with Feyerabend. The nature of science itself is independent of the human experience. How we choose to perceive natural phenomena does not make it an absolute reality.

Methodical changes in method:

Feyerbend objects to staunch observance of the scientific method, assuming that it is a universal and unchanging structure that adheres to all scientific investigation. In his mind, a scientist should follow their own method provided that they disclose the reasoning behind it. Chalmers responds with an intermediate perspective. There are “historically contingent methods” within science that we must adhere to in order to be successful. At the same time, we must maintain a level of dynamism and innovation in our methods that furthers scientific development. This is especially true for burgeoning soil characterization techniques, which must balance the concrete data derived from NMR analyses with efforts to increase the efficiency and detail at which this data is acquired. With this in mind, changes in our methods must develop incrementally to effectively build up and enhance the existing framework.

 

97f4ef00b27eedceaf1cff401301ab42

Feyerabend’s anarchistic theory of science:

Theories as structures II: Research programs

 

We are now aware of the shortcomings of inductivism, falsification, and the purported progression of scientific discovery. How can we now integrate these philosophies?

In an attempt to modify falsificationism and the structure of scientific development, Imre Lakatos coined the phrase “research programs” in the 1950s. These programs can be thought of as an alternative structure to Kuhn’s paradigms. Lakatos contends that not all components of a science have the same weight—some parts are more rudimentary than others. Scientists can then actively redistribute the weight they prescribe to each component as they see fit. That is, the fundamental principles of a research program, what Lakatos calls the hard core, can be augmented or diminished depending on circumstance. The hard core is protected from falsification by a series of supplemental hypotheses known as the protective belt.

Ideally, a progressive research program will “retain its coherence” and produce innovative predictions that are ultimately confirmed. A degenerative program will do the opposite; it will lose coherence and may fail to confirm its predictions. Proponents of this structure should be careful of how they communicate their work between communities. The hard core of one research program may differ from another, creating a less transferable platform to exchange data. This structure may help facilitate development within discrete research groups at the expense of the larger community. I imagine that this structure is most successful when the participating programs clearly and explicitly describe their hard core, as well as their rationale behind it.

Theories as structures II: Research programs

Theories as structures I: Kuhn’s paradigms

Science must be moderated by a paradigm in order to have value. Without a proper paradigm, a scientific investigation may find itself flailing aimlessly in a vast sea of disconnected observations and ideas. Vague and imprecise by nature, paradigms govern observations and experiments alike. They are comprised of fundamental laws and assumptions, along with the necessary instrumentation and techniques needed to link the paradigm to real world phenomena. In short, a paradigm should be imprecise enough to encourage open-ended investigation, yet clear in its underlying laws and assumptions.

The paradigm is the skeletal foundation of scientific research—the beams structuring an ever-growing tower. However, the internal structure of science is as dynamic as the scientific community itself. These conclusions can be drawn from Thomas Kuhn’s book, The Structure of Scientific Revolution. Kuhn asserts that science develops structure and direction upon the adoption of a paradigm by the scientific community. Kuhn calls the collective utilization of a paradigm to address scientific problems is called normal science. Advances in the field may eventually inspire a paradigm shift, or a scientific revolution, which will lead to new ideas and breakthroughs. These developments will then proceed in an ongoing cycle. Kuhn thus outlines scientific progress in the following sequence: pre-science, normal science, crisis, revolution, new normal science, new crisis.

But is scientific development truly so simple? Tom Stoppard’s play Arcadia comes to mind. The 19th century protagonist, Thomasina Coverly, bursts into flames upon discovering chaos theory and the second law of thermodynamics ahead of the mathematic and scientific communities. Surely such epiphanies, although rare and unlikely, are not impossible—as both Kuhn and Stoppard seem to suggest.  I am also reminded of plot diagrams frequently discussed in my writing classes. Every story starts with an exposition, followed by rising action, climax, falling action, and resolution. Although Kuhn’s theory is compelling, I am inclined to believe that scientific progress cannot be so linearly defined. Although the larger community may adhere to a paradigm, individuals may differ in their opinions, knowledge, and understanding of the paradigm itself. For all we know, these subtle discrepancies may drive scientific progress itself as new ideas emanate from unconventional sources.

740123

 

 

Theories as structures I: Kuhn’s paradigms

The limitations of falsificationism

We have seen that falsificationism complements our goal to derive scientific theory from observable facts. We have also seen it that encourages scientific growth and development via perpetual ad hoc modifications, which are geared to make theories both as falsifiable as possible, yet (ideally) not falsifiable. Even so, the application of falsificationist philosophy to scientific issues is not straightforward, as Chalmers aptly points out in this chapter. Observational and experimental data may yield evidence that appears to falsify a law or theory. However, the evidence itself may be at fault rather than the law or theory itself.

As an example, soil organic matter analysis techniques are currently being refined to quantify and assess soil organic carbon and the complex processes driving its accumulation and loss.

Differences in data quality between near-infrared versus mid-infrared spectroscopy illustrate Chalmers’ point about the limitations of falsificationism. Although NIR can clearly identify aliphatic carbon within SOM, MIR yields stronger and clearer signals than its counterpart. An erroneous reliance on NIR data could thus lead to the falsification of existing knowledge about SOM composition—soil fractions may appear to have less chemical and physicochemical diversity than in reality. The unique background and experience of the scientist becomes important in this case. Their knowledge in the associated field will determine how and if they bypass these limitations.

montage-industrial-fence

The limitations of falsificationism

Sophisticated falsificationism, novel predictions and the growth of science

Chalmers asserts that scientists should seek to design hypotheses that are as falsifiable as possible, yet still are not able to be falsified. The rationale here is that theories should be based on observable facts and experiments. A solid theory will then be resilient to experimental data with the potential to disprove it. But because the extent at which a theory can be falsified cannot be explicitly defined (or limited, for that matter), it is necessary the consider the relative falsifiability between theories.

For example, my dissertation will likely examine the implied mutual exclusivity of soil carbon storage and soil productivity. The presence of fertile and carbon-rich Amazonian and African dark earths falsifies this paradigm, opening new insight on soil organic matter functionality. However, the degree to which soil carbon storage and productivity overlap and diverge is still unclear. Falsificationism, by that note, is not a concrete concept. Only by comparing one theory to another are we able to get a sense of the falsifiability of a given theory.

Although theories should become more falsifiable, we must be wary of adding modifications to theories to protect them from potential falsification. Chalmers thus stresses the need for ad hoc modifications, which have no testable consequences that were not already present in the unmodified theory. Characterization of SOM will help determine the drivers for soil carbon storage and productivity. This observational data can be added incrementally to our knowledge of soil carbon to develop a more comprehensive and unbiased theory.

Sophisticated falsificationism, novel predictions and the growth of science